Player Jack Wighton

[captainsutto]

This confirms I'm right if captionsutto disagrees

Well, your usual lame duck response was expected.
now, you’ve puffed out your chest, you can death ride Jack for 5ne next 3 years….as you do

Me? I gave you constructive thoughts, you don’t agree and respond l8ke a childish dunce

 

[Sonic Star]

Well, your usual lame duck response was expected.
now, you’ve puffed out your chest, you can death ride Jack for 5ne next 3 years….as you do

Me? I gave you constructive thoughts, you don’t agree and respond l8ke a childish dunce

Yeah don't reply to my posts, don't need to see your lack of brains, lame jokes and dribble.

Thanks

 

[captainsutto]

Yeah don't reply to my posts, don't need to see your lack of brains, lame jokes and dribble.

Thanks

yet you keep embarrassing yourself

 

[Pplspoet]

I'm saying in this current team he is going to be wasted in that position.

Can't compare NSW with our side now.

If we were a top 4 side or even a top 8 side then it could work.

no guarantee the board will admit mistake and sack JD.

Right now we need him at fullback or at five-eighth.

I appreciate your solution-focussed approach, but no chair switching gets us out of this hole.

The club need to move on from the coach.

Then we can talk selections and rebuild.

While JD is here, we’ll see the same.

And that’s nothing against JD (like
It was nothing against Madge), but when elite sports teams across the board stop playing for the coach, all the positional swapping in the world isn’t going to save things.

Whatever the message is at the moment, it’s not getting through. And that leads to players trying to problem solve in isolation, which leads to errors and elite players looking like they are reserve graders.

 

[Sonic Star]

I appreciate your solution-focussed approach, but no chair switching gets us out of this hole.

The club need to move on from the coach.

Then we can talk selections and rebuild.

While JD is here, we’ll see the same.

And that’s nothing against JD (like
It was nothing against Madge), but when elite sports teams across the board stop playing for the coach, all the positional swapping in the world isn’t going to save things.

Whatever the message is at the moment, it’s not getting through. And that leads to players trying to problem solve in isolation, which leads to errors and elite players looking like they are reserve graders.

Pretty much most know JD needs to go now.

Even the PR people on this forum are starting to see that.

But we leaked a lot of points on that side of the field and we were lucky they didn't put the 50 number on us.

Wighton and AJ looked very shaky defending out there and cody is on that side with them which makes it worse.

Sad to say but we looked better defensively with kennar.

The wrong chairs get switched when JD does make changes, Hawkins is basically another Illias type half back, I voted for Gray to play there.

Cook needed to be benched but I prefer he was dropped but Mamo needed to be hooker, not havili.

Trells liabilities at fullback cost us too much points, he needs to be moved ASAP.

Cody used up his last chance for me last night, he needs a stint in reserve grade as well.

No point keep picking them if they keep dishing up the same garbage eack week.

We been playing the exact same style for years and it's easy to shut down, even the lesser teams are able to do it now.

The coach refuses to make real changes which means nothing changes.

 

[Rabbits21]

He is not a centre, especially in this current team.

I mean if the team was in form and everything was clicking then he could do a job there but he was lost out in sea in defence and barely got the ball in attack.

I had my concerns and was hoping for the best with him playing there.

It was his first game he was always gonna be a bit rusty let’s see how he goes next few weeks do not overreact after one game. Can’t judge after one game

 

[captainsutto]

The 2nd half in particular , after Walker took more control, Jack made quite a few incisive runs down the left. He also created space for AJ which Kennar & Tass haven’t done for 2 years
Ran for over 150m but this clown thinks he did nothing

Did he object to the signing previously?…..that may be a clue

 

[Sonic Star]

It was his first game he was always gonna be a bit rusty let’s see how he goes next few weeks do not overreact after one game. Can’t judge after one game

My judgement isn't based off one game, I watched him play centre last year as well.

Watching him play other positions in his career to know where he is best suited and I don't think it's centre unless it's a rep quality side

I made a post before his debut last night that I don't think he will be playing centres for his whole time at souths and that it might not even last for this season.

 

[captainsutto]

My judgement isn't based off one game, I watched him play centre last year as well.

Watching him play other positions in his career to know where he is best suited and I don't think it's centre unless it's a rep quality side

I made a post before his debut last night that I don't think he will be playing centres for his whole time at souths and that it might not even last for this season.

And regardless of the good he does as a centre for the next 3 years you’ll ignore it and push the same dumbarse barrow
Last night is proof

 

[kor3]

My judgement isn't based off one game, I watched him play centre last year as well.

Watching him play other positions in his career to know where he is best suited and I don't think it's centre unless it's a rep quality side

I made a post before his debut last night that I don't think he will be playing centres for his whole time at souths and that it might not even last for this season.

The issue is he is a better Centre than anyone else we have with Stretch out, unless you swap him and Latrell. For what he lacks as a centre, it was refreshing to see at least one of our back 5 make metres last night.

 

[Sonic Star]

The issue is he is a better Centre than anyone else we have with Stretch out, unless you swap him and Latrell. For what he lacks as a centre, it was refreshing to see at least one of our back 5 make metres last night.

I rather wighton fullback and trell centre any day of the week

 

[kor3]

I rather wighton fullback and trell centre any day of the week

That would be the only move to make if you want to move him. Just don’t love the thought of making one position stronger by weakening another especially if it meant Kennar at centre again .

 

[rabbitohleigh]

Pretty much most know JD needs to go now.

Even the PR people on this forum are starting to see that.

But we leaked a lot of points on that side of the field and we were lucky they didn't put the 50 number on us.

Wighton and AJ looked very shaky defending out there and cody is on that side with them which makes it worse.

Sad to say but we looked better defensively with kennar.

The wrong chairs get switched when JD does make changes, Hawkins is basically another Illias type half back, I voted for Gray to play there.

Cook needed to be benched but I prefer he was dropped but Mamo needed to be hooker, not havili.

Trells liabilities at fullback cost us too much points, he needs to be moved ASAP.

Cody used up his last chance for me last night, he needs a stint in reserve grade as well.

No point keep picking them if they keep dishing up the same garbage eack week.

We been playing the exact same style for years and it's easy to shut down, even the lesser teams are able to do it now.

The coach refuses to make real changes which means nothing changes.

Exactly Sonic, and last night is even worse and should accelerate JD’s demise as, following the off season review, he was the self appointed defensive coach!!

112 points conceded!!!!!

 

[captainsutto]

Great to hear him after the game talk about the pride in the jumper and scoring for us. It was genuine and passionate

His performance was wonderful and is clearly going to be a big threat on our left.

No more talk about him not being a centre. It’s madness to suggest it

 

[Prowsey]

He had a pretty strong game tonight.

Starting to show the value he will bring to Souths.